A visitor arrives on your website, ready to explore your services. The page looks polished, but the text is difficult to read. The navigation works only with a mouse. The contact form highlights an error without explaining what went wrong.
That visitor may leave without completing their task—or telling you why.
These barriers can be easy for a website team to overlook. When you regularly use the same device and browsing method, you may never encounter the difficulties other visitors face. These Web Accessibility Mistakes can affect how visitors interact with your website.
A website accessibility audit helps uncover those gaps. Combined with an accessibility checker and manual testing, it can reveal where design decisions prevent people from reading content, navigating pages, or contacting your business.
What Is the Website Accessibility Gap?
The accessibility gap is the difference between what your website allows some visitors to do and what others can accomplish.
A menu may work well for someone using a mouse but remain unavailable to someone navigating with a keyboard. An image may communicate important information visually while providing no equivalent for a screen reader user.
Accessibility considers these different ways of perceiving, understanding, and interacting with content.
For businesses, the practical question is straightforward: can people complete the tasks your website invites them to perform?
1. Low Contrast Makes Important Information Hard to Read
Light grey text on a white background may fit a minimal design, but some visitors will struggle to read it. Text placed over photographs can become difficult to distinguish as the image or screen size changes.
The problem becomes especially disruptive when it affects instructions, prices, or form errors.
What to fix: Check foreground and background combinations, including links, buttons, and interaction states. Avoid relying on color alone to communicate meaning. For example, pair a red error border with a clear written explanation. W3C identifies sufficient contrast and alternatives to color-only information as basic Accessibility Best Practices.
2. Navigation Works Only With a Mouse
Hover menus and custom controls can appear functional during a quick visual review while remaining unusable through a keyboard.
People who are blind or have certain mobility disabilities may depend on keyboard interfaces or assistive technologies that use them. A control that cannot be reached or activated can block the entire journey.
What to fix: Test essential tasks without a mouse. Navigate through links, open menus, operate dialogs, and complete forms.
Check that the current keyboard position is visible and follows a sensible order. Pay particular attention to cookie banners and pop-ups that could prevent access to the rest of the page.
3. Images Leave Out Essential Information
An image can carry information that nearby text never explains.
Examples include a promotional banner containing an offer, an icon-only booking button, or a chart showing research findings. Without an appropriate alternative, some visitors may miss the message or misunderstand the control.
What to fix: Choose text alternatives according to the image’s purpose:
- Describe the essential information in informative images.
- Explain the action or destination of functional images.
- Use empty alternative text for purely decorative images.
- Provide a fuller text explanation or data table for complex charts when needed.
W3C’s guidance emphasizes context and purpose when deciding what alternative text an image needs.
Avoid filling alt text with keywords. Its purpose is to communicate information that would otherwise be unavailable.
4. Forms Make Visitors Guess
A form may look simple while hiding several barriers.
Placeholder text disappears as someone types. Required fields are identified only by color. An error message says “Invalid input” without explaining the correction.
These problems can interrupt someone who is ready to request a quote, book a session, or start a trial.
What to fix: Give fields persistent, programmatically associated labels. Explain required formats before submission and identify errors in clear language. Preserve valid entries so users do not have to start again.
Provide a clear success confirmation, too. Visitors should know whether the submission worked and what happens next. Clear labels and identifiable feedback are central parts of Accessible Website Design.
5. Headings Create a Visual Layout Without a Useful Structure
Large, bold text may look like a heading without being marked up as one.
Conversely, a designer may choose heading levels according to font size, producing a page structure that does not reflect the relationship between sections.
This matters because headings help people understand a page’s organization, and assistive technologies can use them for navigation.
What to fix: Use descriptive headings that follow the content’s hierarchy. Choose their visual appearance through styling rather than selecting an inappropriate heading level.
A visitor should be able to scan the headings and understand what the page covers before reading every paragraph.
6. Buttons Are Too Small or Too Close Together
Tiny controls can turn a straightforward action into repeated attempts.
A small close icon or tightly packed group of buttons may be difficult for someone with limited dexterity to activate accurately. The same layout can also frustrate people using a touchscreen.
WCAG 2.2’s Level AA target-size criterion specifies a minimum of 24 by 24 CSS pixels, with defined exceptions that include sufficient spacing and inline targets. Larger controls can still be more usable than the minimum. This criterion is one consideration when evaluating WCAG Compliance.
What to fix: Review the clickable area as well as the visible icon. Increase control size or spacing where needed, and test important actions on mobile devices.
Include less obvious controls such as calendar arrows, carousel buttons, and dialog close buttons.
What an Accessibility Checker Can—and Cannot—Tell You
An accessibility checker can help identify certain detectable problems across multiple pages, such as missing accessible names, some contrast failures, or structural issues.
However, detection is only part of the assessment.
A tool may identify an image with alt text without knowing whether that text explains the image accurately. It may detect a heading structure without determining whether the headings make sense.
W3C states that no tool alone can determine whether a website meets accessibility standards; knowledgeable human evaluation is required.
Use automated findings to guide investigation. Treat a clean scan as useful evidence about the checks performed, rather than proof that every visitor can use the website.
Automated accessibility tools are valuable for detecting common technical issues, but they cannot fully evaluate how people experience a website. Keyboard navigation, screen reader interactions, and the clarity of form instructions often require human evaluation. Understanding the difference between automated and manual accessibility testing can help website teams build a more complete testing process and identify barriers that automated scans may overlook.
How to Run a Useful Website Accessibility Audit
Start With Important User Journeys
Select tasks that matter to your visitors: finding a service, comparing products, completing registration, or sending an enquiry.
Include different templates and interactive states. A homepage review will not reveal every problem inside a booking flow.
Combine Automated and Manual Checks
Scan for detectable issues, then review keyboard operation, screen reader interactions, zoom behavior, content clarity, and form feedback.
Where practical, involve people with disabilities in usability testing. Their experience can reveal barriers that a technical checklist misses.
Record the Effect on the User
A useful finding explains more than the failed check. Record:
- Where the issue occurs.
- Who may encounter the barrier.
- Which task it affects.
- How to reproduce it.
- What needs to change.
This gives designers and developers enough context to make a meaningful repair.
Prioritize Blockers and Shared Components
A keyboard-inaccessible menu used throughout the website may deserve attention before a minor issue on a rarely visited page.
Fix shared templates and components carefully, then retest the affected journeys. Continue evaluating accessibility as the website changes; W3C recommends checking early and throughout development.
Not every accessibility issue has the same impact on visitors, which makes prioritization an important part of website improvement. Problems involving keyboard navigation, unreadable text, or inaccessible forms can prevent users from completing essential tasks. Exploring what to fix first during a website accessibility audit can help teams focus on critical barriers and create a more practical remediation plan.
Make Your Website Easier to Use
Small design decisions can create substantial barriers. A difficult form, unclear control, or inaccessible menu may prevent an interested visitor from taking the next step.
A regular website accessibility audit helps your team find these problems and verify improvements. An accessibility checker supports that work by identifying issues that need attention, while manual testing adds essential context.
Elite Site Optimizer can help teams review accessibility findings, including contrast, image alternatives, and form-related issues. Combine those insights with human evaluation to prioritize repairs around real user tasks.
Maintaining an accessible website requires ongoing evaluation as new content, design elements, and interactive features are introduced. Accessibility reports can help teams identify recurring issues, understand their severity, and organize improvements based on user impact. Learn how Elite Site Optimizer supports website accessibility and compliance through accessibility scanning, reporting, and actionable recommendations.
Start by checking whether every visitor can complete your website’s most important journey.
Ready to improve your website’s search performance?
Sign up for Elite Site Optimizer and start analyzing your website’s SEO, accessibility, performance and content quality.
Start Your Free Signup